Conservatorships

Contested Conservatorships in California

A contested conservatorship is a court fight over whether an adult needs a conservator, who it should be, or whether the person already serving is doing the job. In California the court can appoint a conservator of the person for someone unable to provide for their own health, food, clothing or shelter, and a conservator of the estate for someone substantially unable to manage finances or resist fraud or undue influence, under Probate Code section 1801. The standard of proof is clear and convincing evidence. Malachowski & Associates represents families petitioning for a conservatorship over a parent being exploited, and families fighting a conservatorship that is unnecessary or in the wrong hands.

Three kinds of conservatorship disputes

  • Whether a conservatorship is needed at all. The proposed conservatee, or a family member, opposes the petition and argues the person is capable or that a less restrictive alternative exists.
  • Who should serve. Siblings file competing petitions. The court chooses by statutory priority under section 1812 and by the proposed conservatee’s preference, but can bypass both for cause.
  • How the conservator is behaving. A conservator who isolates the conservatee, mismanages money, overpays themselves or fails to account can be surcharged and removed under section 2650.

What the court must find

Under section 1801, clear and convincing evidence that the person cannot provide for personal needs, or is substantially unable to manage finances or resist fraud or undue influence. Isolated incidents of negligence or improvidence are not enough. The court investigator interviews the proposed conservatee, the person has the right to counsel and to a jury trial on the question of whether a conservatorship is needed, and the court must consider less restrictive alternatives.

Alternatives the court considers

  • A durable power of attorney and advance health care directive already in place
  • A revocable trust with a successor trustee who has stepped in
  • Supported decision-making agreements, recognized by California law since 2023
  • A limited conservatorship tailored to specific decisions

A petition that ignores these invites opposition.

Conservatorship as an elder abuse tool

When a parent with diminished capacity is being drained by a new “friend,” a caregiver or one child, a conservatorship of the estate is often the fastest way to freeze the accounts, revoke a power of attorney and claw back transfers. Temporary conservatorship can be granted on an emergency basis under section 2250. The same court can hear the elder financial abuse claim.

How a contested conservatorship proceeds

  1. Petition, with a capacity declaration from a physician or psychologist.
  2. Court investigator’s report and appointment of counsel for the proposed conservatee.
  3. Objections from the conservatee or family members; competing petitions if any.
  4. Temporary conservatorship where there is immediate risk.
  5. Discovery, mediation and an evidentiary hearing or jury trial.
  6. Ongoing supervision: inventory, accountings and periodic court review.

Frequently asked questions

How do you overturn a conservatorship?

Petition to terminate under section 1860 with evidence that the conservatee has regained capacity, or petition to remove the conservator for cause.

Can you do a conservatorship without a lawyer?

Uncontested ones, sometimes. A contested one is litigation with expert testimony and should not be attempted without counsel.

What are the alternatives to conservatorship in California?

Powers of attorney, health care directives, trusts, supported decision-making and limited conservatorships.

How long does a contested conservatorship take?

Temporary orders in days or weeks. A contested general conservatorship can take six months to a year.

Who pays?

Fees for the conservatee’s counsel and often the petitioner’s counsel are paid from the conservatee’s estate when the court finds the petition was brought in good faith and in the conservatee’s interest.

This page explains California law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change; the code sections linked above are the current text on the California Legislature’s website.

How Mark helps

For families on either side of the petition

Petitioning

Protecting a parent who is being exploited, including emergency temporary orders.

Opposing

Fighting a conservatorship that is unnecessary or in the wrong hands.

Competing petitions

When siblings disagree about who should serve.

Conservator conduct

Surcharge and removal of a conservator who is not doing the job.

The process

A clear path from first call to resolution

01

The facts

Medical evidence, finances and the alternatives already in place.

02

The filing

A petition or objection, with temporary orders where the risk is immediate.

03

The hearing

Mediation where it works, an evidentiary hearing or jury trial where it does not.

A conservatorship fight in your family?

Whether you are filing or opposing, the first hearing comes fast. Call Mark before it does.

Call 415-983-0717