Who can contest a will
An “interested person”: an heir who would inherit if the will were invalid, a beneficiary under a prior will, or anyone whose share changes if the contest succeeds. A disinherited child, a spouse left out of a later will, and a beneficiary cut from an earlier version all have standing. A friend with no stake in either version does not.
Grounds for a will contest
- Lack of testamentary capacity. Under Probate Code section 6100.5, the testator must understand the nature of the act, the nature of their property and their relationships to the people affected, and must not be suffering a mental disorder with delusions that cause the disposition. Dementia alone does not prove incapacity; the evidence is medical records, witnesses and the circumstances on the day of signing.
- Undue influence. Pressure that overcame the testator’s free will, usually by a caregiver, a new partner or one child. Welfare and Institutions Code section 15610.70 lists the factors: vulnerability, the influencer’s authority, the tactics used and the inequity of the result. See the undue influence page.
- Fraud. The testator was deceived about facts or about what they were signing.
- Duress. Threats or coercion.
- Improper execution. A formal will needs the testator’s signature and two witnesses present at the same time under Probate Code section 6110. A holographic will needs the material terms and signature in the testator’s handwriting under section 6111. A will that fails these can still be admitted if the proponent proves by clear and convincing evidence that the testator intended it as a will.
- Revocation. A later will or a physical act of revocation.
The two windows
- Before admission. When a petition for probate is filed, any interested person may file objections under Probate Code section 8250 before the hearing. The court then tries the contest before deciding whether to admit the will.
- After admission. Under section 8270, an interested person has 120 days after the will is admitted to petition to revoke probate, unless they were already a party to a contest or had notice of one. A minor or incompetent person without a guardian can petition any time before final distribution.
Miss both and the will stands, however strong the evidence.
How a will contest proceeds
- Review the will, prior wills, the drafting attorney’s file, medical records and the circumstances of signing.
- File objections or a petition to revoke probate in the county where probate is pending. San Francisco Superior Court for San Francisco decedents.
- Discovery: depositions of the drafting attorney, witnesses, caregivers and the beneficiaries who gained; subpoenas for medical and financial records.
- Mediation, which resolves most contests.
- Trial before a probate judge. There is no jury in a California will contest.
Will contest vs trust contest
Most Bay Area estates pass by trust, not will. A trust contest is a petition under Probate Code section 17200 with a 120-day deadline running from the trustee’s notice under section 16061.7, not from a court order. If the decedent had both a pour-over will and a trust, both may need to be challenged. See the contest a trust page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the time limit to contest a will in California?
Before the will is admitted, or within 120 days after admission under Probate Code section 8270.
How much does it cost to contest a will?
It depends on whether the case settles at mediation or goes to trial. Malachowski & Associates reviews the will and the evidence before advising whether the contest is worth bringing.
What are the odds of winning?
Contests with medical evidence of incapacity, a beneficiary who was the caregiver and a last-minute change have the strongest footing. Contests based on unfairness alone rarely succeed.
Does a no-contest clause stop me?
Only if the contest is brought without probable cause. See the no-contest clause page.
Can a will be contested after probate closes?
Generally no, except for minors and incompetent persons under section 8270(b), and in cases of extrinsic fraud.
This page explains California law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change; the code sections linked above are the current text on the California Legislature’s website.
