Real property

Tenancy in Common Disputes in San Francisco

San Francisco has more tenancy in common buildings than any city in the country, a product of condo conversion limits that have been in place since the 1980s. A TIC gives each owner an undivided fractional interest in the whole building and an exclusive right to one unit under a private TIC agreement. When one owner stops paying, wants out, dies, or refuses to sign the refinance, the TIC agreement and California partition law decide what happens. Malachowski & Associates litigates TIC disputes across San Francisco and the Bay Area.

The disputes we see most

  • A co-owner stops paying their share of the group mortgage, taxes or insurance, and the others are covering it.
  • A co-owner wants to sell and the group will not approve the buyer, or the market for the fractional interest has dried up.
  • Disagreement over a special assessment, a roof, a seismic retrofit or a unit remodel.
  • A co-owner has died and the heirs, or a trust, now hold the interest.
  • The group mortgage is maturing and one owner will not cooperate with the refinance or a move to fractional loans.
  • One owner has taken over common areas or rented their unit in violation of the agreement.
  • The building wants to convert to condos and one owner is blocking it.

The TIC agreement controls first

A well-drafted San Francisco TIC agreement covers default, cure periods, forced sale of a defaulting owner’s interest, buyout formulas, dispute resolution and often mandatory mediation or arbitration. Enforcement starts with the agreement: notice of default, the cure period, and the remedies the owners agreed to. Many agreements require arbitration, which means the dispute never sees a courtroom but still needs litigation counsel.

When the agreement fails: partition

A tenant in common has a right to partition under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.210, unless they waived it, and most TIC agreements include a waiver for a period of time or while the group loan is outstanding. Where the waiver has expired or does not apply, a partition action forces a sale of the building and a division of proceeds, with credits for each owner’s contributions to the mortgage, taxes, insurance and improvements. See the partition page.

Death of a co-owner

A TIC interest passes by will, trust or intestacy like any other real property. The heirs step into the agreement, including its obligations. Problems arise when the interest is in a trust that was never funded, which is a Heggstad petition issue, or when a reassessment hits because the transfer is not a parent-child exclusion under Prop 19.

Condo conversion

San Francisco’s condo conversion lottery has been suspended since 2013 and its return has been pushed back repeatedly. Two-unit buildings where both units are owner-occupied by separate owners for at least a year can still convert without the lottery. For larger buildings, conversion is not currently a route out of the TIC, which makes the TIC agreement and partition rights more important.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get out of a tenancy in common?

Sell your interest under the agreement’s procedures, negotiate a buyout by the other owners, or, if the agreement allows, bring a partition action.

Can a tenant in common force a sale?

Yes, by partition, unless partition was waived in the TIC agreement. Most San Francisco agreements waive it for a period, so the agreement is the first thing to read.

What happens to a TIC when one owner dies?

The interest passes to the heirs or trust beneficiaries, who take it subject to the TIC agreement.

Is it hard to sell a TIC?

Harder than a condo. Fractional financing is available but at higher rates and with fewer lenders, and the group often has approval rights.

Can we remove a co-owner who will not pay?

If the agreement provides a forced-sale remedy on default, yes, following its procedure. Otherwise through partition and an accounting for the amounts they owe.

This page explains California law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change; the code sections linked above are the current text on the California Legislature’s website.

How Mark helps

Getting out of, or protecting, a TIC

Defaulting co-owners

Enforcing the agreement’s default, cure and forced-sale terms.

Buyouts and exits

Negotiating a way out when the group or the market will not cooperate.

Arbitration

Litigation counsel for disputes the agreement sends out of court.

Inherited interests

Heirs and trustees stepping into a TIC after a death.

The process

A clear path from first call to resolution

01

The agreement

Default terms, waivers and dispute resolution, read first.

02

The remedy

Enforcement under the agreement, or partition where it no longer applies.

03

The resolution

A buyout, a sale or an award that divides the building fairly.

A TIC co-owner dispute?

The agreement decides most of it. Call Mark and have it read before anyone sends a default notice.

Call 415-983-0717