Probate litigation

How to Remove an Executor or Administrator in California

An executor or administrator in California can be removed by the probate court for wasting, embezzling or mismanaging the estate, for being incapable of doing the job, for neglecting the estate, or whenever removal is necessary to protect the estate or the people interested in it. That is Probate Code section 8502. Any interested person can petition under section 8500, and the court can suspend the executor’s powers immediately while the petition is heard. Malachowski & Associates brings removal petitions in San Francisco and Bay Area probate courts.

Grounds under Probate Code 8502

  • Waste, embezzlement, mismanagement or fraud on the estate, or being about to commit it
  • Incapacity or lack of qualification
  • Wrongful neglect of the estate, or long neglect to perform any act
  • Removal otherwise necessary to protect the estate or interested persons
  • Any other statutory cause

Courts read these broadly. An executor who has not filed an inventory a year in, who is living in the estate’s house, who will not return calls, or who has a conflict with the estate’s largest asset is exposed.

What removal looks like in practice

  • No inventory and appraisal filed within four months of appointment.
  • Estate property sold to a relative or friend without court confirmation.
  • Estate funds in the executor’s personal account.
  • Rent collected and unaccounted for.
  • Refusal to provide information to beneficiaries.
  • Hostility that makes administration impossible.
  • Pursuing a personal claim against the estate while running it.

How the petition proceeds

  1. Petition for removal under section 8500, with a request for immediate suspension under section 8505 where assets are at risk.
  2. Request for an accounting. An executor who cannot account is usually removed.
  3. The executor responds. The court may appoint a special administrator to take over in the meantime.
  4. Hearing. The court can remove, surcharge the executor for losses, deny compensation, and refer misconduct to the district attorney.
  5. Appointment of a successor: the alternate named in the will, or an heir with priority under section 8461, or a professional fiduciary.

Removal vs surcharge

Removal stops the damage. Surcharge recovers it. Under Probate Code section 9601 the personal representative is chargeable with losses from a breach of duty, and section 859 provides double damages where property was taken in bad faith. Both are usually pleaded together. See breach of fiduciary duty.

Frequently asked questions

Can an executor be removed without a court hearing?

No. An executor is a court appointee and only the court can remove them. The court can suspend powers immediately pending the hearing.

How long does an executor have to settle an estate in California?

The executor must file a status report or petition for final distribution within one year of appointment, or 18 months if a federal estate tax return is required, under section 12200. Missing it is grounds for removal.

Can an executor take money from the estate?

Only as court-approved compensation and reimbursement. Anything else is surcharged.

Who becomes executor after removal?

The alternate named in the will, then the heirs by statutory priority, then a professional.

How much does it cost to remove an executor?

If the executor’s misconduct is proven, the court can charge the cost to the executor personally.

This page explains California law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change; the code sections linked above are the current text on the California Legislature’s website.

How Mark helps

When the executor is the problem

Suspension

Asking the court to stop the executor at once when assets are at risk.

Removal

Proving a ground under Probate Code 8502 at the hearing.

Surcharge

Recovering what the estate lost while the executor was in charge.

A successor

Putting the alternate, an heir or a professional fiduciary in place.

The process

A clear path from first call to resolution

01

The record

Inventory, accounts and the court file show what the executor has and has not done.

02

The petition

Removal, with suspension where the estate needs protecting now.

03

The handover

A successor appointed and the estate put back on track.

An executor who is stalling or taking?

The court can suspend them while the petition is heard. Call Mark about the estate.

Call 415-983-0717