What counts as a breach
- Self-dealing: buying trust property, lending trust money to themselves, living in trust real estate without paying rent.
- Favoring one beneficiary, often themselves or their own children.
- Failing to account or to provide information.
- Imprudent investing or leaving assets idle for years.
- Commingling trust funds with personal funds.
- Paying themselves excessive compensation.
- Selling real estate below market to a friend or relative.
- Failing to distribute when the trust requires it.
- Delegating everything to a third party without supervision.
What the court can order
Under Probate Code section 16420, the court can compel the trustee to perform, enjoin a breach, compel the trustee to redress the breach by paying money or restoring property, appoint a receiver, remove the trustee, reduce or deny compensation, set aside a transaction, and trace trust property into the hands of a third party. Under section 16440, the measure of damages is the trust’s loss, the trustee’s gain, or the lost profit, with interest. Section 16440(b) lets the court excuse a trustee who acted reasonably and in good faith, which is why the evidence of bad faith matters.
Double damages and attorney fees
When the trustee’s conduct is also financial elder abuse, or the trustee took property in bad faith, Probate Code section 859 allows twice the value of the property taken, plus attorney fees. Welfare and Institutions Code section 15657.5 adds attorney fees and costs in elder financial abuse cases. These provisions change the economics of a case against a trustee who drained an elderly settlor’s trust. See undue influence and elder financial abuse.
The deadline
Probate Code section 16460: three years from receipt of an account or report that adequately discloses the claim, or three years from when the beneficiary discovered or should have discovered it if no adequate account was given. A trustee who never accounted has not started the clock.
How a surcharge petition proceeds
- Demand an accounting and the trust’s financial records.
- Forensic review of bank statements, property records and distributions.
- Petition under section 17200 for surcharge, removal and, where the facts support it, double damages under section 859.
- Suspension of the trustee and appointment of a temporary trustee where assets are at risk.
- Discovery, mediation, and trial before the probate judge.
Frequently asked questions
How hard is it to prove a breach of fiduciary duty?
Self-dealing and failure to account are proven from the records. Imprudent investment and bad judgment are harder and turn on expert testimony.
What is reasonable compensation for a trustee in California?
What the trust says, or if silent, reasonable compensation under section 15681, measured against the work done and local practice. Trustees who pay themselves professional rates for unprofessional work are surcharged.
Can I recover attorney fees?
In elder abuse and bad-faith taking cases, yes. In ordinary breach cases, the court can charge the trustee’s own defense fees to the trustee personally rather than the trust.
Is the trustee personally liable?
Yes. A surcharge is a personal judgment against the trustee, not against the trust.
What if the trustee is my sibling?
Most of these cases are. The duties do not change because the trustee is family.
This page explains California law in general terms. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes change; the code sections linked above are the current text on the California Legislature’s website.
